Where is it that your piece is set that there just aren’t any POC there? I mean, I’m sure there are places like that. Wherever it is that white people fly to when they take white flight comes to mind. Maybe you’re writing a story set in a gated community in the suburbs of…
While I agree with most of your argument, I feel it necessary to point something out. In Japanese animation, it usually appears as though the vast majority of characters are white. But even though characters are sometimes depicted with blond hair or blue eyes, it is used as a design choice to differentiate between characters that are all native Japanese. They are not drawn to look caucasian, but rather depicted the way the Japanese view themselves. Blond hair in an animated character would be used to illustrate that someone has a lighter shade than most of the other characters. The reason I wanted to say this is that while I agree with your statements on Disney films, which could be more racially diverse, I would argue that animation is style, and therefore can be interpreted by the eye of the beholder. An asian, a caucasian or a hispanic could (and in my opinion should) be drawn exactly the same, if it’s done in a stylized way. I loved Disney’s Mulan, but I didn’t see the need to make every character have narrow eyes. As far as I’m concerned, narrow eyes are something a caucasian would see as different, but an asian wouldn’t notice about another asian. To draw attention to such little differences creates racial boundaries, rather than blurs them.
Ok, if you’re trying to apply the principle of Mukokuseki to western animation re: Disney in a way that implies that Disney characters like Snow White, Aurora, Ariel, Rapunzel, and Merida can possibly be interpreted as anything but white, you’re being really disingenuous.
The fact that Disney’s prevailing style treats white as default and feels the need to have other races depicted in especially stylized, often samey-faced ways is a valid discussion, and one worth having, but it is not the discussion that was put forth above. I will have your back if you want to write an essay going ‘Yo Disney, what gives with all of your Asian characters being drawn with catty eyes and flowing black locks, completely ignoring the actual racial/ethnic/phenotype diversity of China?’




